Benlowndes

a perspective on PR in social housing and regeneration

Plagiarism plagues the press at all levels

Protest the Pope - 23 - Johann Hari vs Benedict

Johann Hari (Photo credit: lewishamdreamer)

The issue of journalists plagiarising content has hit the headlines recently, most notably with the Independent’s Johann Hari last year.

He was derided as the symbol of unethical journalism in the ‘cut and paste’ age for lifting passages from the work of others to embellish his copy. Having made a name for himself by criticising the wrongs of others, the industry was never going to give him a sympathetic hearing once he was found out.

I don’t have sympathy for him either, but the rest of the media is in no position to crow about this practice in my view; what, after all, does that make the press releases regularly published at all levels of the media?  It isn’t plagiarism in the sense that Hari’s activity was, sure. But it is little more than ‘cut and paste’ reporting in many respects.

There are a couple of things recently that have brought this subject closer to home for me and added to my suspicion that this becoming more common.

The first was a story about the editor of the Reading Chronicle (where I used to work) complaining that the BBC was lifting their stories.

Writing in a column for the paper, Sally Stevens called for political action to:

“..tell the BBC off for paying 60p a week for our reporters’ hard work so its radio presenters can read a page lead out every day masquerading as its own news bulletin and castigate other newspapers for copying and pasting our online news onto their own websites.”

Then, today, I was surprised to read a story in a regional daily, which quoted a ‘HCA spokesman’ (ie me) in relation to an interview with a colleague that was broadcast on BBC radio at 7.30am and online later that day. The story wasn’t damaging, but it wasn’t entirely correct either, and no-one called me to check the facts before publication, let alone offer a right of reply. They simply reported the radio exchange as their own work. The spokesman was my colleague. I’ll be pinging a letter to the editor tomorrow; the temptation to cut and paste The Chron’s criticisms above will be resisted.

There are different degrees of plagiarism, as demonstrated by the examples above. But nicking content from competitors matters because cutting corners is how mistakes are made. Readers and listeners are cheated by the bogus suggestion that such content is authentic and self-generated. That, in turn, damages trust and puts people off.

Responsibility for this rests with those at the top of the media organisations which have been squeezed over the last 20 years while such a culture has grown. We can all agree that it’s wrong. But with other people’s content the click of a mouse away, and increasing pressure on reporters to deliver quickly with a skeleton staff, is it surprising that some fall for the temptation to rip others’ work off and claim it as their own?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

SPeye Joe (Welfarewrites)

Joe Halewood writes about tenant and welfare wrongs

Barney's Blog

Regeneration, Development, Economics, Cities

FragmeNTs

from the National Trust archaeology team in the Stonehenge & Avebury World Heritage Site

newgatecommunications.wordpress.com/

Insight. Ideas. Influence.

bristoljames.com

a blog about adapting to the digital age

A Cup of Lee

Digital Communications in Ireland

Photos from here, there and everywhere

Pictures I've taken, images I like

Colin Wiles

Commentary on current housing and planning issues

Awesome Screenshot

The Easiest Way To Communicate With Images

Man in the Krowd

Talking Openly, Speaking Privately

4,000 bricks

A place for housing, communications and political debate

AdeCapon's Blog

All things digital, marketing, football and happenings

Decisions, Decisions, Decisions

A blog about better decisions, better urban planning and better economics

John Wade

Joining up the planks

Simon Rogers

Data journalism and other curiosities

David Higgerson

Journalism, online, random thinking

Connecting Social Care and Social Media

Sharing resources to promote the use of Social Media in Social Care

John Popham's Random Musings

"Just trying to matter"

The Housing Blog

It's about housing, stupid

Rob Jefferson

Web & Digital Manager for @MyDoncaster | Outdoor adventurer by feet, peddles & paddles

nick atkin

A collection of random views on housing, technology & running

%d bloggers like this: